Ohio Resource Center
[blank]

How can I teach my students the difference between summarizing and retelling?

For many students, the difference between summarizing and retelling is unclear. Both have their usefulness, but when it comes to the OGT and the OAT, students need to know the difference since they may be asked to summarize a passage or select the best summary.

It is often helpful to explain the difference this way:

  • A summary is direct and to the point—it is like a postcard of your vacation—whereas retelling is the entire scrapbook.
  • Retelling provides all the intricate details of a reading, from beginning to end.

One method I've used for teaching students the difference between summarizing and retelling is a "somebody-wants-but-so-then" chart. This gives students a framework for identifying the essential elements of a summary: the setting and characters, the plot, the conflict, the solution, and the conclusion (or prediction). After the students and I complete a reading (I usually choose a picture book—it is short, easy to analyze, and an attention grabber), I model summarizing by putting this chart on the board:

SOMEBODY
(Setting, characters)
WANTS
(Character's wish)
BUT
(Conflict)
SO
(Solution)
THEN
(Conclusion or prediction)
         

We complete the chart as a class. The goal is for students to eventually use this strategy with their independent readings.

Below is an example that my class did with the picture book Goldilocks Returns, written by Lisa Campbell Ernst.

Summary: Goldilocks Returns by Lisa Campbell Ernst
SOMEBODY
(Setting, characters)
WANTS
(Character's wish)
BUT
(Conflict)
SO
(Solution)
THEN
(Conclusion or prediction)
         
One day
After 50 years
Goldilocks
Decides it's time to make amends with the 3 bears for destroying their home. When she arrives, the bears are out on their daily walk. Goldilocks remodels their house and replaces the porridge with healthy food. The bears arrive home, none too happy, but Goldilocks gives them a hug good-bye and leaves thinking they love what she did to their cottage.

Although I use a picture book for modeling the strategy, the strategy can be applied to almost any narrative or expository text. As a case in point, the Conflict Dissection section of "Tools for Reading Writing, and Thinking" displays a similar graphic organizer with a nonfiction example.

Another strategy for helping students summarize comes from Sarah Dennis-Shaw in "Guided Comprehension: Summarizing Using the QuIP Strategy." By using the QuIP (questions into paragraphs) strategy, students learn to summarize by graphically organizing information and synthesizing it in writing. And by synthesizing, students improve their reading comprehension. This strategy can be used cooperatively or independently.

Finally, in the article "Scaling Back to Essentials: Scaffolding Summarization with Fishbone Mapping," Kathleen Donovan-Snavely describes how to identify recurring and related details to determine main ideas. Donovan-Snavely includes lesson plans to extend student's learning by having students use the Internet to explore one or more of the main ideas from the reading. Finally, students cluster ideas to develop a detailed summary in their own words.


2/19/2008 | Posted by Shannon Bumgarner
Shannon Bumgarner has been an educator for twenty years, during which time she has taught special education, first grade, Title One reading, and fifth grade and has also served as a literacy specialist. She has provided professional development for several school districts and presented book studies on various teacher resources. She has been a SIRI instructor since 2000.
 
Previous Posts
How can we teach questioning skills from the perspective of deconstruction?
 
How can I help students become familiar with their textbook at the beginning of the year?
 
What can I do to help students learn critical vocabulary in my content area?
 
How do we help students respond fully to extended-response questions in a testing situation?
 
Why do mathematics teachers owe it to their students to use reading strategies in their classrooms? What reading strategies might they use?
 
What does effective questioning look like, and how can I teach questioning skills to my students?
 
What can I do to help the challenged spellers in my classes?
 

How should we engage reluctant readers?

We as teachers know that the most effective way to become a better reader is to read, and to read a lot! But try telling that to a middle or high school student who can read but doesn't like to and sees little value in doing so. "Who cares?" is the usual answer when such a student is pressed about his or her lack of reading. So how can we inspire our students to become engaged readers?

The ORC online magazine Adolescent Literacy In Perspective has devoted a number of issues to this topic. Three stand out as being particularly relevant. The March 2006 issue, "Boys and Reading," speaks to the problem of motivation. The May/June 2006 "Young Adult Literature: Books That Engage Tweens and Teens," focuses on young adults and fiction and includes recommendations for specific books. The October 2004 issue, "When Adolescents Can't and Won't Read," lays a comprehensive foundation for this entire topic.


2/5/2008 | Posted by Nancy Peirce
A retired curriculum director (Oregon City Schools), Nancy Peirce has been an education consultant for various school districts, the Ohio Department of Education, and the Department of Youth Services. She is an Ambassador for the Ohio Resource Center and is a member of the ORC Reading Review Panel. She is also an approved SIRI instructor.

How can students at different reading levels read the required content-area text?

As teachers, we are constantly questioning how to manage the reality that more and more students struggle to read assigned texts. In "Fostering Comprehension in Content-Area Reading," Jeffery Williams offers a framework for dealing with the two issues at hand: (1) students who don't have strategies to read the texts and (2) texts that are difficult to assess and understand. No matter the reason students struggle, it is clear that simply assigning chapters and lecturing about the text is not sufficient to ensure comprehension of important content material.

Here are some ideas to consider:

Think-alouds. Choose a section from your content-area textbook, and use a think-aloud to model what an effective reader looks. Laura Robb presents excellent suggestions in her article "Model Reading Strategies to Improve Comprehension for All Students." Robb explains, "When you show with think-alouds how a strategy works, students can step inside your head and better understand how the strategy supports reading."


1/22/2008 | Posted by Jackie Wissman
Jackie Wissman worked at Indianola Elementary in Columbus Public Schools for ten years as both a classroom teacher and Literacy Collaborative Coordinator. She has her MA from Ohio State University with a focus on reading development. She currently teaches Adolescent SIRI and works as a consultant to provide professional development focusing on supporting struggling adolescent readers.
We welcome your questions about adolescent literacy. Please send them to editor@ohiorc.org. We may not be able to post every question but will respond to all of them.